Please be advised that Otter Insurance Agency is not and has never been affiliated with Otto Insurance. Learn More.

Companies We Represent

With us, you have options.

Here are the insurance companies we currently work with. Already a customer? Feel free to use the provided links or phone numbers to manage your account.

CBIC

CBIC

Manage Account Online

Phone: Washington & Oregon: 800-765-2242
All Other States: 800-788-3006

Foremost

Foremost

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-527-3905

GeoVera

GeoVera

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-785-2181

Grange Insurance Group NW

Grange Insurance Group NW

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-546-8850

Hagerty

Hagerty

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-922-4050

HCC Surety

HCC Surety

Manage Account Online

Phone: 303-649-9163

Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.

Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-526-1547

Mapfre

Mapfre

Manage Account Online

Phone: 855-627-3732

Mutual of Enumclaw

Mutual of Enumclaw

Manage Account Online

Phone: Weekdays: 877-425-2580 (7am – 5pm, PST)
Evenings and Weekends: 866-924-3036

Progressive

Progressive

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-776-4737

RLI Surety

RLI Surety

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-444-0406

Safeco Insurance Co. of America

Safeco Insurance Co. of America

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-332-3226

Travelers

Travelers

Manage Account Online

Phone: Personal: 800-252-4633
Business: 800-238-6225

Zurich

Zurich

Manage Account Online

Phone: 800-987-3373


Need an insurance quote? Get in touch!

Access quotes from Washington's most trusted insurance carriers. It’s comparison shopping at the click of a mouse.